The Secret Italian

+44 1226 244888

McLintock Way, Barnsley S70 6BF United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Open Today: Closed

Quick Facts About The Secret Italian

The Secret Italian place has received overwhelmingly positive reviews from customers. The strengths of the restaurant can be identified through the comments provided. One of the main strengths highlighted is the quality and taste of the food. Customers consistently mention how delicious and flavorful the dishes are, praising the freshness and authenticity of the Italian cuisine. This indicates that the restaurant has a strong focus on using high-quality ingredients and ensuring that each dish is prepared with care.

The portion sizes and value for money also received positive mentions. Customers appreciate the generous servings, with some mentioning that they were even offered to take home any leftovers. This attention to detail and customer satisfaction enhances the dining experience and makes customers feel valued. The affordable prices for the multiple courses offered are seen as great value for money.

The customer service at The Secret Italian place is another strength mentioned in the comments. Several customers highlight the welcoming and friendly demeanor of the staff, in particular, Margaret and Jana. Their interactions with customers create a warm and inviting atmosphere, and they take the time to chat and provide additional information about the dishes. This personal touch adds to the overall dining experience and makes customers feel well taken care of.

The set menu format is appreciated by customers, although some mention initial apprehension, especially for vegetarians. However, the fact that even vegetarian customers thoroughly enjoyed the dishes speaks to the restaurant's ability to cater to different dietary needs and preferences. The option to tailor certain dishes to individual tastes is also mentioned, showing a willingness to accommodate customer preferences.

The atmosphere and ambiance of The Secret Italian place are positively commented on. Customers describe it as a small, cozy venue, off the beaten track, and the name "secret Italian" suggests a hidden gem. This adds to the overall charm and uniqueness of the restaurant and contributes to a memorable dining experience.

While the comments primarily highlight the strengths of The Secret Italian place, there are few weaknesses mentioned. One potential drawback is the limited number of covers due to its small size. This may lead to difficulty in securing a reservation, especially during peak times. However, this can also be seen as a positive aspect, indicating its popularity and the high demand for its dining experience.

In conclusion, The Secret Italian place has several strengths that make it highly recommended by customers. The delicious and flavorsome food, generous portion sizes, and affordable prices contribute to its positive reputation. The welcoming and friendly staff create a warm atmosphere, while the personal touches and ability to cater to different tastes add to the overall satisfaction of diners. The small and cozy ambiance, coupled with its unique dining experience, makes The Secret Italian place stand out. The limited number of covers may be a downside for some, but it also reflects the high demand and popularity of the restaurant. Overall, the strengths of The Secret Italian place far outweigh any potential weaknesses, making it a highly recommended dining experience.

Best TL Reviews

Our first time here and what a gem of a restaurant, the Valentine's menu was delicious, 6 starters before the main meal and then the desserts. All the food had so many flavours, we were Absolutely stuffed.

You won't be disappointed with this Italian.

Margaret and Jana are so welcoming.

Many thanks Chris & Allison.

Me and my partner were lucky enough to get a cancellation. I'd heard about it and read the reviews so we were looking forward to it and we were not disappointed! My partner is a vegetarian and it's a set menu so he was a bit apprehensive. However, he enjoyed every single dish and so did I...could not fault anything! The dessert is a Tiramisu and I've never been a fan but I have to say that was one of the best desserts I've ever had! The service was outstanding from start to finish,especially Jana who cooked and spoke to every customer in between...she is amazing!

We visited for the first time this evening 13/10/22 it was a delightful experience. The food was delicious and plentiful, anything you couldn’t finish was offered to be boxed up for taking home, a special touch I thought. The cost of the entire meal was great value considering the many courses.The service was spot on, both chef and waitress were very pleasant and took time to interact with the customers. It is a small cosy place off the beaten track, hence the name secret Italian. We have booked again for my birthday in January and I can’t wait. Thank you for an extremely pleasant evening ladies.

From Helen and Andy Dean

I heard about this little place from a relative, he suggested a visit.

So we went in, astounding! The food was all freshly prepared, wonderful, authentic Italian, I have traveled Italy from the top to bottom, it took Me back. I will definitely be returning.

You definitely need a big appetite!

Margaret and her Team are so very welcoming. Give it a go.

First time we’ve eaten here and not disappointed! Fantastic yet simple food, welcoming staff who took the time to chat after our meal and give us some background and discussed the ingredients in detail. I said how I was not a massive chicken fan (though it was really good) and was told to ask beforehand as it could be tailored more to my tastes. Desert was a highlight tasted even better than it looked, we will be back here again!

I experienced the secret Italian last night, one word PERFECTION. The food was amazing, i am self confessed fussy with food but enjoyed every mouthful and there was many. The food is plentiful, fresh and full of flavour. The staff were all lovely, efficient and welcoming. Thank you so much for a lovely evening, credit to you all.

Wow. The best dining experience. The food is fantastic and Claudia/Margaret are amazing. We will definitely be booking back in. The only down side is that it is so long before we can go back.

This is unlike any restaurant you've visited before and more like being invited to dinner by an Italian family. One sitting, no menu, bring your own drinks and have a thoroughly wonderful experience. Not a "fine dining"place but lovely Italian cooking. Very few covers so book well in advance, you'll not be disappointed.