Carbones Beachside

+1 315-762-4280

1208 Main St, Sylvan Beach, NY 13157 United States of America

Open Today: Closed

Quick Facts About Carbones Beachside

Carbones Beachside Place is a restaurant and accommodation establishment with a range of strengths and weaknesses based on the comments provided.

Starting with the strengths, one customer had a positive experience with their dinner at the restaurant. They mentioned that the ribs were very good and their wife enjoyed the delicious chicken soup. Additionally, they noted that the server was attentive and friendly, providing good service. The cozy atmosphere on a chilly rainy night was also appreciated, and this customer expressed their intention to return in the future.

Moving on to the weaknesses, one customer had an extremely negative experience with their stay at the accommodation. They found mold on the ceiling in multiple areas, encountered hair in the bathtub, experienced issues with the sink not draining, and noted a horrific smell in the bathroom. They also mentioned finding food all over the floor upon arrival, indicating that the room had not been cleaned prior to their stay. The presence of musty smells and black mold further added to their dissatisfaction. They remarked that the management did not seem to care about these issues.

Another customer expressed disappointment with the restaurant's food. They expected a larger BBQ selection but found the menu to be small. The pulled pork sandwiches they ordered were described as dry and tasteless. They did enjoy the fries, but found the coleslaw to be overly dressed and peppery, which they did not enjoy. The customer also mentioned that the waitress was nice but lacked knowledge about the beers on tap. They highlighted that one table left without eating their food because it was cold, and their own sandwiches were only barely warm. Additionally, the customer found the interior to be "ugly," even though they expected an interesting renovation. They did mention a clever mermaid skeleton hanging from the ceiling.

Another negative experience was shared by a customer who visited the restaurant when it had just opened. They ordered a beet salad, which arrived as just six cut-up beets on a plate, without any lettuce or other ingredients. The customer also ordered wings and a taco salad but found that many items on the menu were already out of stock. They returned to the restaurant a second time and ordered a BBQ burger, which they found to be a regular cheeseburger instead. They experienced sickness after eating and expressed that the restaurant seemed more focused on drinking than on providing good food. The previous establishment at the same location was praised for its good food and reasonable prices, which the customer felt were lacking in Carbones Beachside Place.

Another dissatisfied customer mentioned various issues during their visit to the restaurant. They waited for 25 minutes for two sandwiches that were supposed to be made with beef ends but were served with dried-out pork instead. One of the sandwiches was missing two items that were supposed to be included. They also received rotten salt potatoes and cold French fries. The customer noted that they were seated in an area without air conditioning on a 95-degree day. They observed the neighboring couple leaving most of their meal because of the heat and claimed their own meal was disgusting. In addition, the bus person asked about the neighboring couple's meal and eventually took away the customer's meal as well. This comment also suggested that the restaurant needed improvements to prevent losing customers.

Despite the negative comments, there were positive aspects mentioned by some customers. One customer enjoyed the barbecue at the restaurant, although they noted that some food was on the greasy side. They remarked that the taste was good overall, but also mentioned a long wait for lunch due to a shortage of staff.

Finally, a customer had a positive experience with the food at the restaurant. They ordered the garbage plate and found it to be magnificent, while their lunch date enjoyed the fish dinner special. They praised a young man named Brad, who provided excellent service and a pleasant dining experience. As a former waitress, the customer appreciated seeing a young man waiting tables.

In terms of the accommodation, one customer mentioned that the room was clean and the staff were courteous. However, they felt that the price was too high for the small size of the room.

In conclusion, Carbones Beachside Place has received mixed feedback based on the comments provided. Positive aspects include good food, attentive service, and a cozy atmosphere. However, there are several weaknesses, including issues with cleanliness, lackluster food, poor menu choices, and problems with management and service. These comments suggest that improvements are needed in various areas of the establishment to provide a better overall experience for customers.

Best TL Reviews

Was a quiet Sunday evening dinner. First time we've been there. Was a very nice dinner. I had ribs. They were very good. My wife had chicken soup and it was delicious. It was very slow and our server was attentive and friendly. The place is cozy on a chilly rainy night. We will return!

The most disgusting place I’ve ever stayed for an absolutely outrageous price. Mold on the ceiling in multiple areas, hair in the bathtub, the sink didn’t drain, the bathroom smelled horrific, food all over the floor when we first arrived. The room had obviously not been cleaned prior to our stay. It smelled musty with large areas of black mold in the bedroom and entryway. Management did not seem to care either.

Went here expecting a large BBQ choice. Menu small. Had pulled pork sandwiches. They were the most dry tasteless pork sandwiches ever. The FF were good. The coleslaw was hot and peppery with too much dressing, horrible. The waitress was nice but not knowledgeable of the few beers they hv on tap. One table left without eating thier food because they said it was cold. Our sandwiches were barely warm. Its really ugly inside too. I was expecting they had remodeled in an interesting way. No. They did hv a mermaid skeleton hanging from ceiling, clever.

Want there when they opened (should not of opened ) ordered a Beat salad that was 6 cut up beats on a plate no lettuce nothing just the cut up bests the waitress was embarrassed to serve it order 10 wings and a taco salad 3 drinks $80 . Left said ok they just opened will try them later after they been open for some time and get there stuff together. Everything on there made up menu was out . So I try them again yep samething out of this out of that ok give me the BBQ burger and fries. Yep $20.00 for that . I eat half the burger half the fries not a barbecue burger just a regular cheeseburger and 10 minutes after eating got sick . If you like to drink that’s the place to go I guess. Other then that I would not recommend this place . The restaurant that was there before had such good food and A reasonable price and very family oriented this place not even close .

Not a place we will ever return to. Waited 25 minutes for two "dead ends" sandwiches should have been beef ends but came with dried out pork, my sandwich was missing two of the items they offered with it, rotten salt potatoes, cold french fries, sat us on a 95 degree day in an area with no ac. The couple next to us left 75% of their meal because they couldn't take the heat & said their meal was horrible. Bus person literally asked us if the people across from us had left or were coming back most of their dinner was still there. We said they left & you can take our meal too, its disgusting, we paid & left. For a brand new place they need to do something or they will have nothing.

The barbecue was good. Some food was a little on the greasy side. Tasted good. Long wait for lunch as they were short help.

Wonderful food! I ordered the garbage plate and it was magnificent. My lunch date ordered the fish dinner special and he was very satisfied. The young man, I think his name Brad? Either way he was very accommodating and smiled the entire time. He was a delight. I am a former waitress and it was so nice to see a young man waiting tables. He was great.

Reserved a spot on off season was very expensive for very small room. Very clean and courteous but way too much for such a small room