All Star Bagel Manasquan

+1 732-800-3200

95 Atlantic Ave, Manasquan, NJ 08736 United States of America

Open Today: -

Quick Facts About All Star Bagel Manasquan

All Star Bagel Manasquan has received a mix of positive and negative reviews from customers. In order to provide a comprehensive analysis, the comments will be categorized into strengths and weaknesses.

Strengths:

1. Quality food: Several customers have mentioned the delicious taste of the bagels and breakfast sandwiches. The bagels are described as freshly baked and flavorful. The sandwiches are praised for their quality ingredients, such as the rare and lean roast beef. The cream cheese is also mentioned as being generous and well-balanced.

2. Good hash browns: One customer specifically praises the hash browns for their perfect texture and flavor. They highlight the middle ground between being too dry or too greasy, which makes them an ideal choice for breakfast.

3. Fruity pebble bagel: The mention of a fruity pebble bagel suggests that All Star Bagel Manasquan offers unique and creative flavors, appealing to customers looking for something different.

4. Excellent customer service: Multiple customers commend the customer service at All Star Bagel Manasquan. Emily is mentioned by name as providing spectacular service for an over the phone order. The owner is also praised for being engaged in the business, making sandwiches, baking, and ringing up customers. Additionally, the owner's willingness to listen to customer feedback and solve problems is highlighted as a positive.

5. Regular customers: One customer states that they and a group of friends have become regulars at All Star Bagel Manasquan. Their loyalty demonstrates the satisfaction they have with the food and service.

Weaknesses:

1. Incorrect orders and confusion: Some customers express dissatisfaction with their orders. One customer received an incorrect sandwich, with only one egg instead of the expected amount. Another customer experienced confusion at the counter when their everything bagel was mistaken for a roll. These instances reflect a lack of attention to detail and accuracy on the part of the staff.

2. Mixed bagel quality: While the overall opinion of the bagels is positive, one customer describes them as average. This comment indicates that there might be inconsistency in the quality of bagels at All Star Bagel Manasquan.

3. Lack of iced coffee: One customer mentions the absence of iced coffee on the menu. This could be a drawback for those who prefer cold beverages or during hot weather.

In summary, All Star Bagel Manasquan has several strengths, such as delicious food, good hash browns, unique flavors, excellent customer service, and a loyal customer base. However, there are also weaknesses, including incorrect orders, potential inconsistency in bagel quality, and the absence of iced coffee. These areas of improvement should be addressed to ensure a positive dining experience for all customers.

Best TL Reviews

Really good food. I am currently staying at a motel and as this place is just down the road I decided to try them out. I got a Cherry Coke, a tomato basil bagel and cream cheese and two hash browns.

The bagel was very tasty. They put a good amount of cream cheese on it and the bagel tasted fresh. Being a tomato basil bagel I was a bit nervous the flavor would be too much but it was actually a perfect balance.

The hash browns were also good. I am a bit of a critic when it comes to hash browns because some places make them either way too dry or too greasy. These hash browns had the perfect middle ground. The type you want to eat with breakfast.

Overall I am glad I gave this place a try as the food was very good. They also have a fruity pebble bagel so might have to give that a try in the future as well.

5 out of 5 stars.

Customer Service from Emily just now for an over the phone order was spectacular! These Bagels are delish! See you tomorrow when I pick up the order!

Thank you Again All Star Bagel !!!

I ordered bacon egg and cheese on a roll..... They put one egg on My sandwich.... That's just low class In my book....

Bagels are average. Though they make good breakfast sandwiches. Good service

Definitely not happy with my past service, waited online for at least 15-20 minutes to get the wrong order. How do you mistake everything bagel for a roll? I have no idea, but when Scott was owner of this company I’ve never had any issues until now. The girl at the counter, when I told her the order was wrong Just stared at me with a blank look in her face like she was confused although she was the one that took my order. Definitely not happy with my past 2 experiences being here.

Great customer service, the owner waited on me was refreshing to see an so happy an engaged in his business! Made me the best sandwich, and it was the first time I was every in here!! I stopped in because I was getting my hair cut and another client was in raving about how amazing all the food was.. That he goes four or five times a week. He was right... Definitely coming back in!!

Bagels are delicious.. I had Roast Beef on an everything Bagel and the Roast beef was rare and lean, so good. The owner is very nice and is a hands on owner, he was making sandwiches, baking and ringing customers up!!! I recommend this place for breakfast or lunch!

This place rocks. I found them on Yelp after a long journey for a good breakfast spot at our beach house. The 8 of us now come every Saturday and Sunday. We tried every single other bagel place and they were all terrible. The grand slam is a master piece. The staff is all very nice. We have probabaly spent a good 500$ total there over the course of the last few weeks. I don't really know how more people don't know about this hidden gem. Thank you for making my hang over a little less miserable every Saturday / Sunday. I do wish they had iced coffee but their hot coffee is great. Thank you owner for solving a problem with your great business