Idyllwild Pizza Company

+1 951-659-5900

54391 Village Center Dr, Idyllwild-Pine Cove, CA 92549 United States of America

Open Today: -

Quick Facts About Idyllwild Pizza Company

Idyllwild Pizza Company has several strengths that make it a popular local spot. One major strength is the variety of food options they offer. They not only have a wide range of pizzas, but also salads and sandwiches for those who prefer lighter meals. This allows the restaurant to cater to a diverse group of customers with different preferences.

Another strength is the atmosphere of the place. It is described as having a community pub welcoming feel, which creates a comfortable and relaxed ambience for customers. The staff also receives praise for their friendly and efficient service, adding to the positive experience of dining at Idyllwild Pizza Company.

The quality of the food is also mentioned as a strength in multiple comments. Customers appreciate the fresh and delicious dough and cheese used in the pizzas. The garlic bread sticks are described as phenomenal, with a soft and flavorful texture. The Hawaiian pizza specifically receives praise for being outstanding and not greasy. These positive comments indicate that the overall taste and quality of the food is a strong aspect of Idyllwild Pizza Company.

The availability of outdoor and indoor seating is another strength. Customers mention that there are high chairs available for children, making it a family-friendly place. The self-service water, restrooms behind the bar, and the option to order at the counter are all convenient features that contribute to a smooth dining experience.

The fact that the restaurant accepts credit cards is also seen as a strength, although there is a $5 minimum. This allows for easier payment and adds to the convenience factor for customers.

Furthermore, Idyllwild Pizza Company seems to be popular among large groups and children. The comments mention that it is good for both, with the availability of high chairs and the portion size of pizzas being suitable for sharing among four people. This indicates that the restaurant has the capacity and accommodations to cater to larger groups and families.

Despite these strengths, there are a few weaknesses that can be inferred from the comments. One weakness is that the line can get long quickly, even when the restaurant has just opened. This suggests that there may be a limited capacity or that the popularity of the place can cause longer wait times during peak hours.

Another weakness is that the pizzas are described as being on the smaller side. While some customers appreciate the portion size, others mention that it may not be sufficient for those with larger appetites or for sharing. This might be a drawback for customers looking for larger portion sizes or for those dining in larger groups.

Lastly, there is a comment from a long-time customer suggesting that the restaurant has changed over time. While the comment still recommends Idyllwild Pizza Company, it implies that it may not be exactly the same as it once was. This suggests that there have been changes to the menu or overall experience of the restaurant, which may not appeal to all customers.

In conclusion, Idyllwild Pizza Company has several strengths that contribute to its popularity. These include the variety of food options, the welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and the quality of the food. It is also praised for being suitable for large groups and families. However, there are some weaknesses, such as potential long lines, smaller portion sizes, and changes to the restaurant over time. Despite these weaknesses, Idyllwild Pizza Company continues to be a recommended and popular local pizza place.

Best TL Reviews

Local pizza spot with beer and an arcade. Came here for lunch at 11:30am (right when they opened) and there was a short line already. Indoor and outdoor tables are available. Credit cards accepted but there’s a $5 minimum. We had a large Tahquitz Supreme pizza to share among four people and that was a good portion for everyone to get 2-3 slices each. They have salads and sandwiches for those who don’t want a heavy meal.

This is good for large groups and for children. They have high chairs available. Water is self-service. There are restrooms behind the bar. You order at the counter and then they’ll call your name once the food is ready.

I love this place. My 2nd time here. I will be back again. My GMA got the supreme I got the veggie gourmet . I gave up meat for lent. So we shared a large pizza half and half. So delicious. Also had the buffalo wings. And the brushetta. The wings were soft and tender. Could use more buffalo sauce.

So very good… the dough is fresh and taste amazing as well as the cheese. If you loved home made pizza stop by and have it here.

Called in on a whim, asked for a recommendation for the best experience and she had a few great offers and went with the first. Arrived to an atmosphere that had a community pub welcoming feel and the fellow that packaged our pizza had an enthusiasm for life and was very helpful offering all the right things we would have been lost without.

The pizza, well that was incredible, even the dressing for the salad made me wanting more. Would like to have gone back for a sit down meal experience but we were only in Idyllwild for a couple days and still wish we had come back the next night. :)

Great little place with quality bites. Was debating between the garlic bread and cheesy bread sticks... Never going to have that debate again - the bread sticks were phenomenal. Soft, flavorful, and with herbs to kick up the flavor ????????. The Hawaiian pizza was outstanding and not at all greasy. The cashews add a lovely crunch but the pickled ginger brought out a whole new dimension of flavor. Will be returning on my next Idyllwild visit for sure!

Went there today after hiking all day…best pizza for a 50 mile radius of town…got a chicken Alfredo and feta cheese pizza…have one slice left and if any of my housemates eat it…you can contact me in prison????

Good service, good pizza, good beer selection.

Got pizza to go and had a beer while we waited. They had Michelob Amber Bock on tap. Felt like I was transported back to the 1990s.

Pizzas are on the smaller side, so take note if you're looking to share or your really hungry. I ate an entire medium by myself, but I'm a bit of a piggy when it comes to pizza.

I've been coming to Idyllwild Pizza Company for 25 years, and I've seen it change a lot in that time. It's still good, maybe not exactly the same as it once was, but it's still definitely worth going. The pizza is good, the sandwiches are good, the beverage selection is good, and the service is friendly and efficient. Hard to go wrong.