New York by The Slice

+1 843-917-0388

921 W Carolina Ave, Hartsville, SC 29550 United States of America

Open Today: -

Quick Facts About New York by The Slice

New York by The Slice place has several strengths and weaknesses based on the comments provided. Overall, the food and service receive positive feedback, while the pizza flavors and portion sizes may be areas for improvement.

Starting with the strengths, many customers praise the quality and taste of the food. The pasta and wings, in particular, receive high ratings and are described as "amazing" and "delicious." Customers express their intention to order these items again in the future. Reviewers also compliment the bread used in dishes such as the tuna melt, with one customer specifically stating that it was the best-tasting bread they have had. The garlic knots are mentioned as another highlight and are described as the "best I have ever had." The reasonable pricing is also highlighted as a positive aspect, making the restaurant accessible to a wide range of customers.

The service at New York by The Slice place is frequently mentioned as another strength. Multiple comments praise the waitstaff and mention specific servers by name. Words such as "amazing," "attentive," and "on point" are used to describe the service experience. The importance of the waitstaff in creating a positive dining experience is emphasized by a customer who states that "the ladies there are an important part of the way their food makes you feel."

Additionally, the restaurant garners positive reviews from various groups, including individuals, couples, and church groups. The positive experiences of these different groups indicate that the restaurant can cater to a diverse range of customers and occasions.

However, there are also weaknesses mentioned in the comments. The pizza receives mixed reviews, with some customers rating it only 6/10. The flavors of the Buffalo chicken pizza and the white pizza are not particularly praised. One comment suggests ordering a slice first to determine if it suits one's taste buds. This inconsistency in pizza quality may be an area for improvement to ensure consistent taste and flavor for all pizza options. Another weakness mentioned is the portion sizes, with one comment suggesting that sharing plates might be necessary for those who cannot eat a lot. This implies that the portion sizes might be too big for some customers, potentially leading to wastage or discomfort.

In conclusion, New York by The Slice place has several strengths, including delicious pasta and wings, excellent service, and reasonable pricing. However, there are weaknesses in terms of pizza flavors and portion sizes that could be addressed to further enhance the dining experience. Nonetheless, the positive comments and recommendations from customers indicate that the restaurant has a strong appeal and a loyal customer base.

Best TL Reviews

Overall the food here is great. We ordered a Large White Pizza, Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza, 10pc Mild Buffalo Wings, and Tortellini Alfredo.

The pasta and wings we would rate 10/10! Absolutely amazing! We will def be ordering these things in future!

The pizza we would rate 6/10. We initially gave it a 5/10 however we upped a point cause the size of them are fairly big. We were not fascinated with the flavor of either pizza. The Buffalo you couldn’t really taste the Buffalo all we could really taste is the marinara. The white pizza was a nostalgic buy for me. The flavor was faintly there.

This of course is mine and my partners opinion. I def would recommend pasta and wings. If you order pizza I would def order a slice of the kind you want to order so you know if it suites your taste buds.

I got a tuna melt and it was delicious. I couldn't stop complimenting on how great the bread tasted. My boyfriend got lasagna with a side salad. I tore his side salad up. Tasted great for a basic salad and he ate most of his lasagna buy kept complaining it was too acidic, because he is use to sugar being mixed in tomato sauce. I took a menu home because I definitely want to go back and try more menu items

Food is great. Service is great. The ladies there are an important part of the way their food makes you feel-grrrr8!

Paul Cannarella (PVC)

I just moved to the area recently and was looking for an Italian place to get my pasta fix and we decided to try this place. It instantly became an addiction! Their pasta is amazing and their garlic knots are the best I have ever had and all their food is at a reasonable price! I have a feeling it won't take long to get to the point where they know my order the minute I walk in the door. Highly recommend!

This the best veggie I have ever had! My friends had the supreme and said the same! Prices are very reasonable! Can't wait to go back!

My 1st time eating here I'm visiting my aunt for the weekend and she wanted me to try it told me how good it is and it did not disappoint. Our waitress Pam was amazing and on point, and very attentive will definitely be going back when I visit Hartsville not only because the food was very delicious but because of our waitress! Thank you!!

A group from our church ate there following a funeral we had attended. We all thought the food and service was superb! We would love to go back!

Be prepared when eatting here lol.if your a BIG Eater your not gonna have a problem. Lol other wise your waitress will ask share a plate ? If you can't eat a lot I suggest to share a plate had a child sitting behind me kept bouncing the bench but over all this place is AWESOME! Go see for yourself all bread Is made from scratch!