Valentine's Restaurant

+1 618-539-9169

205 S State St, Freeburg, IL 62243 United States of America

Open Today: -

Quick Facts About Valentine's Restaurant

Valentine's Restaurant has received mixed reviews, with some customers expressing high praise for the food and service, while others have had more negative experiences. In order to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the restaurant, we will analyze the comments provided.

Starting with the positive feedback, it is clear that the steak at Valentine's Restaurant is highly regarded. Multiple reviewers mention the steak as being "amazing," "juicy," and "the best they've ever had." This consistent praise for the steak indicates that it is a standout menu item and a definite strength of the restaurant. Additionally, the homemade blue cheese dressing and the dinner salad are also highly praised, indicating that the appetizers and salads are well-made and flavorful. The fact that multiple reviewers mention the margaritas as being amazing further suggests that the drink selection is a strength at Valentine's Restaurant.

Another strength that is consistently mentioned is the friendly and attentive service. Reviewers mention specific staff members, such as Donna, who are remembered for their welcoming and friendly attitude. This indicates that the restaurant prioritizes good customer service and has staff members who go above and beyond to make guests feel comfortable. The mention of the restaurant being family-owned also adds to the positive image, as it suggests a personal touch and a dedication to quality.

However, there are also some weaknesses highlighted in the comments. One recurring issue is the slow service. Multiple reviewers mention having to wait for over an hour to receive their food, which is an unacceptable wait time. This suggests a lack of efficiency in the kitchen and could be a major issue for customers who are looking for a quick dining experience. Additionally, one reviewer mentions their steak being cold, indicating a lack of attention to food temperature and quality control.

Another weakness mentioned is the mediocre quality of the non-steak food items. One reviewer describes the rest of the food as being "mediocre at best," suggesting that the restaurant's strengths lie primarily in its steak offerings. This may limit its appeal to customers who are looking for a diverse menu or who have dietary restrictions.

Finally, one reviewer mentions the lack of certain wine options, which indicates a potential weakness in the restaurant's beverage selection and offerings. While this may not be a major issue for all customers, it does limit the restaurant's ability to cater to a wider range of tastes and preferences.

In conclusion, Valentine's Restaurant has several strengths, including its exceptional steak, friendly service, and well-regarded margaritas. However, there are also weaknesses, such as slow service, inconsistent food quality, and limited beverage options, which may impact the overall dining experience. Despite these weaknesses, the positive aspects of the restaurant and the loyal customer base demonstrate that Valentine's Restaurant has the potential to excel and improve upon its weaknesses.

Best TL Reviews

One of the best places me and my husband have ever been. The steak is omg you just got to go get one. All the food A+

Absolutely loved this restaurant. Amazing margaritas! Valentine filet is to die for...so is the ribeye and the dinner salad with there homemade blue cheese dressing will melt in your mouth.

The food tasted pretty good, we had to wait over an hour for it and my steak was a bit cold but I'd go again. It had some nice qualities.

If you've never been out of Freeburg I suppose it was OK. The service was terribly slow, it took over an hour from placing our order to receive our food. The steak was OK, nothing special. The rest of the food was mediocre at best.

Love love love this wonderful family owned restaurant. I have enjoyed every dining experience at Valentine's. Service has always been commendable and I can't say enough how wonderful the food is here. Every salad entree dessert is as fresh as it gets. This family has wonderful work ethic and creates a dining experience like no other in the area. Their menu is delightful and all staff is incredibly professional. Personally, I am grateful for the comfort and peaceful feeling that comes with every dining experience I have ever had at Valentine's restaurant. Kudos to you all you are at the top of your game. Just know that all of your efforts have not went unnoticed and I appreciate each and everyone involved that keeps this quaint little place in business for so many years. That speaks for itself. Bravo. I am your biggest fan.

The Ribeye steak was juicy and cooked to perfection. It was the best steak I've ever had. The staff was welcoming and attentive. our host was Donna and she was super friendly. So glad we chose to eat here. You feel right at home in this cozy family restaurant. I will be going back soon with my family.

The steaks were phenomenal & cooked perfectly. Only issues I had were no Riesling Wine & the Calamari were not fresh, given the small town that was expectable. I had the best cut of meat. A fillet mignon. Well worth the short drive down RT 15.

I feel like this was the first steak I've had in my life. Everything was delicious. Waitress was very friendly. I feel like it could compete with top steak houses in St Louis.