Papa Kelsey's | Pizza & Subs

+1 208-536-2505

379 S Idaho St, Wendell, ID 83355 United States of America

Open Today: -

Quick Facts About Papa Kelsey's | Pizza & Subs

Papa Kelsey's strengths include their unique and delicious pizza, friendly and attentive owner, clean restaurant, and a loyal customer base. Their bread for sandwiches is also highly praised for being light and tasty. Additionally, some customers appreciate the medium crust with a crunchy bottom and the traditional sauce and cheese on the pizza.

One major weakness identified is the high prices for the toppings on the pizza, with customers feeling that they do not receive an adequate portion for the price paid. Some customers also mentioned that both the pizza and the cheesy bread had too much cheese and sauce. Additionally, there were comments about the size of the large pizza being smaller compared to other pizza places, leading to disappointment.

The restaurant space is described as big and open, but it is also mentioned that the entire place needs a deep cleaning. The lack of cleanliness and the uninviting external appearance of the building are seen as weaknesses. Some customers also mention the lack of outside parking as an inconvenience.

Another weakness pointed out is the slow business, which results in the employees sitting in the dining room and having their own social hour instead of focusing on cleaning and attending to patrons. This suggests a potential issue with employee engagement and service quality.

Some customers express a desire for a better atmosphere, mentioning the lack of music and suggesting a portable radio. This suggests that the ambiance of the restaurant could be improved.

Despite the weaknesses mentioned, several customers highly praise the pizza, with one customer even stating that it is one of the best in the region. This positive feedback suggests that Papa Kelsey's has a strong reputation for their pizza.

In conclusion, Papa Kelsey's strengths include unique and delicious pizza options, as well as a friendly and attentive owner. However, weaknesses include high prices for toppings, issues with portion sizes, cleanliness concerns, uninviting building exterior, lack of outside parking, employee engagement, and the lack of atmosphere. Overall, while Papa Kelsey's has a loyal customer base due to their tasty pizza, there are areas for improvement in terms of pricing, cleanliness, and creating a better atmosphere.

Best TL Reviews

Ordered a LG Pepperoni pizza and What I thought was CHEESY BREADx2... tip and all ....NOT WORTH IT!!! $30... IN THE TRASH... CHEESY BREAD IS NOW SERVERED ON A CRUSTY PIZZA CRUST!!! JUST SAD AND HORRIBLE!!... Not sure what happened but horrible food now...

Pizza is different but good. I love the medium thick crust, not deep dish, not thin, but just right. Love the garlic seasoning. Love the thick sliced pepperoni. In my opinion both pies had too much cheese and too much sauce. Prices are high for the toppings you get. Restaurant space is big and open. Entire place needs a deep cleaning. Outside parking is lacking. Building exterior is uninviting. Can't stand when a local spot is a little too local and the employees sit in the dining room and have their own social hour because of slow business instead of cleaning and checking in on patrons.

Had a ham sandwich and the bread was so good. Not heavy. The owner was walking around and talking to all the customers. Very nice and attentive. Very clean.

Pretty good pizza. Friendly counter person and very clean restaurant. Pizza has a medium crust with a nice crunchy bottom. The usual kind of sauce and cheese, pepperoni and mushrooms not liberally placed - could have used more to be an average portion of toppings.

It's my all time favorite sandwich. And it has been my favorite sandwich for over 30 years. I just wish there was as much focus on creating a great atmosphere as there is creating an excellent sandwich. (A portable radio for music?) But I'll be back. And my kids will be back. It's the best!

By war one of the best pizzas in the region. It was worth friving off the freeway for this pizza. Our new must stop by place whenever we're driving by

Mediocre over price pizza, large is about the size of little Caesars and not the size of most pizza places it was fast but wasn't very hot. Do yourself a favor and drive to Zeppes in Gooding if you want pizza, they are larger, better, and cheaper!

Its a basic pizza joint. Probably the best in Wendell. But if you want good pizza at a good price, you have two options, 1. Leave town for pizza, or two, take the time to make yourself. Papa Kelsey's taught me that its worth making myself.