Mama Pepino's

+1 724-872-0338

110 W Main St, West Newton, PA 15089 United States of America

Open Today: -

Quick Facts About Mama Pepino's

Mama Pepino's place has several strengths that contribute to its positive customer reviews. Firstly, many customers appreciate that it is a family-owned establishment and that the owner is actively involved in the day-to-day operations of the business. This hands-on approach likely helps maintain high standards and fosters a sense of authenticity and care.

Another strength of Mama Pepino's is the quality of its food. The comments consistently mention the delicious pizza, with many customers considering it the best in the area. The crust is particularly praised for its perfect texture, being both crunchy and chewy, which suggests that the dough is meticulously prepared. The sauce is also highly regarded, with mention of its sweeter taste being appreciated by some customers. In addition to the pizza, other menu items like subs, breadsticks, cinnamon sticks, and salads are also frequently praised for their taste and portion sizes.

The staff at Mama Pepino's is frequently mentioned in the comments, and their service is highly regarded. Many customers describe the staff as amazing and friendly, indicating that they provide attentive and welcoming service. This level of customer service likely contributes to the positive overall experience at the restaurant.

The business also seems to be accommodating, as evidenced by a customer's comment about placing a last-minute order 30 minutes before closing time. Despite the limited time, Mama Pepino's was able to provide delicious pizza and friendly service, satisfying the customer's cravings.

Additionally, the comment about ordering 7 Big Mamas for a birthday party showcases that Mama Pepino's can handle large orders and cater to events. The fact that the customer plans to order from them again and was excited to have leftovers for the week ahead demonstrates a positive impression of the food and a willingness to return to the restaurant in the future.

While the strengths of Mama Pepino's are evident, there are a few weaknesses that can be identified from the comments. One customer mentions that occasionally the pizza can have a burnt bottom, which is somewhat disappointing. This inconsistency in the quality of the pizza can be perceived as a weakness, as customers may feel uncertain about the outcome of their order.

In conclusion, Mama Pepino's place has several strengths that contribute to its positive reputation. These strengths include the hands-on involvement of the owner, the quality and taste of the food, the attentive and friendly staff, and the ability to cater to large orders. However, there is room for improvement in terms of consistency, as occasional reports of burnt bottoms on the pizza indicate a potential weakness. Overall, the positive feedback suggests that Mama Pepino's is a popular and well-regarded pizza place with a loyal customer base.

Best TL Reviews

Best pizza place around. Family-owned and the owner constantly works beside his employees, not behind or above. My favorite sauce on any pie, great subs, and breadsticks and cinnamon sticks to die for. You won't be disappointed.

Amazing staff!!! Amazing food, salads are huge, pizzas always cooked perfectly! Best Mama Ps in the area hands down!!! Thanks y'all for my yummy gyro salads!! (:

When a craving hit 30 mins before their closing, Mama Pepino’s did not disappoint! Delicious pizza & great, friendly service! Perfect crust, too!

Very surprised how great the dough is. They obviously cold proof their dough and make it days ahead. Otherwise I can't figure out how they get that crunch and that chew in a bite. Sauce was good too. I recall it being sweeter and didn't go back for a long time. I'm so disappointed that I have been missing out coming here since then. Very good. One of my favorites now

Wonderful food and wonderful people. We have never been disappointed when ordering Mama Pepino’s! Always our first choice for pizza and wings.

Sicilian pizza is ❤️‍????Our absolute favorite pie in the world!! Very hard working, team behind the scenes!! Always a wonderful experience!! ????

This pizza is great ! Sauce is sweet if you’re into that type of thing and they make a mean pineapple and ham pizza “Hawaiian” the only thing keeping me from a 5 star review is this …. It is hit or miss to be stuck with a pizza with a burnt bottom. That being said I would order again !

I got 7 Big Mama's for my daughter birthday party. First time ever ordering from there. We were not disappointed! I'll be sure to order from them again! Was excited we over ordered so got some for the week ahead!